Wealth and purpose

Divest or engage? Why selling isn't always the responsible choice

When a company no longer reflects your values, selling feels like the obvious response. But is it the most effective one? Siobhan Archer, Global Head of Stewardship at LGT Private Banking, explains why staying invested can be the harder but more effective choice, and how to tell real engagement from polite conversation.

  • Date
  • Temps de lecture 5 minutes

Making their voices heard: investors who stay invested keep the right to vote on how a company is run. © TF-Images/Getty Image

Key takeaways

  • Selling removes a company from your portfolio, but not the problem from the company. The shares simply pass to another owner.
  • Divestment and engagement are not opposites. They work best as a feedback loop.
  • The number of meetings a manager holds says little. Ask what they asked for, what changed and what they did with the answers.

Is selling the most responsible option when a company disappoints you?

Sometimes, but not always. Selling is certainly the easiest thing to do, but it doesn't necessarily change anything. The economist Albert Hirschman described two options when you disagree with an organisation: you can leave, which he called "exit", or stay and make yourself heard, which he called "voice".

For an investor, exit removes the company from the portfolio, not the problem from the company. The shares go to someone else, who may care far less about how the business is run. Staying invested is harder work: dialogue, voting, resolutions and working with other investors.

So should divestment be off the table?

No. Selling in size can send a message, especially if the company is told why. And some clients simply don't want to own certain businesses or sectors. These are legitimate value decisions. Equally, from a financial viability perspective, investors will want to ensure they're not incurring losses. However, divestment shouldn't be confused with an impactful strategy.

I'd avoid setting engagement and divestment against each other. They should work together as a feedback loop. We regularly ask whether the company is making progress and whether we still have real influence. If the gap becomes too wide, and escalation hasn't worked, reducing or selling the position is back on the table. Stewardship is not a promise to stay invested forever.

More and more companies are listing with unequal voting rights. Why does that worry you?

Stewardship works best when shareholders have real influence, and unfortunately, the listing trends are going towards multi-share structures. Research by Renée Adams and Daniel Ferreira shows that the share of US companies listing with unequal voting rights rose from about 10 % in 2000 to 35 % in 2025. SpaceX, for example, came to market with Class B shares carrying ten votes each, and the Anthropic IPO is set to launch with five different share classes, each with different voting rights attached to them.

Traditionally, a stock market listing is a privilege that gives founders access to public capital. In return, shareholders get rights, above all the right to vote and to appoint the board. So my question to every new listing is simple: what do shareholders actually receive for their capital? If the answer is a share with little or no say, the bargain may begin to look lopsided.

It's one of the reasons we tend to default our preference to "one share, one vote" in our voting policies. Where multiple-vote structures exist, we are back sunset clauses that allow them to expire after a set period. It's a topic of growing importance, and one we plan to highlight our next stewardship report, due in April 2027.

Siobhan Archer, Global Head of Stewardship

Siobhan Archer, Global Head of Stewardship

Siobhan Archer is Global Head of Stewardship at LGT Private Banking. In this role, she is responsible for the strategy behind proxy voting, company engagement, and public policy advocacy across the Europe and Asia. Since joining in 2021, she has built and led LGT's active ownership programme, extending its reach across the firm's full value chain, from listed companies and fund managers to industry-wide collaborative initiatives.

How can investors tell whether engagement actually works?

It's one of the hardest questions in our field. Many managers still believe in only reporting the number of meetings they've held, but that can be very misleading. The industry even has a name for cordial conversations with no real objective: "tea and biscuits meetings".

If a manager tells you they held a thousand meetings, ask three simple questions. What did you ask for? What changed? And what did you do with the answers?

Does engagement only change companies?

No, and that's often overlooked. An exchange can also change our own understanding of a company and, consequently, our investment decision. Information gathered through stewardship can help inform whether we want to buy a security, continue to hold it, sell the position, increase or trim it. That is a dimension that can sometimes be overlooked: stewardship is not only about asking a company to change. It can also improve the quality of an investor's judgement.

This is an issue matters especially for multi-generational clients, with longer term investment horizons. Often, they tend to think in decades and ask what a company will look like in twenty years, how are they navigating the digital or low carbon transitions, rather than what they did last quarter.

So what makes a responsible investor today?

Truly, it's being comfortable with complexity. Selling can be right. Staying and engaging can also be correct. A joint-effort coalition works in one case, a one-to-one conversation in another. Each situation is nuanced and unique. What matters is a rigorous process: knowing what you want to achieve, checking what is actually changing and adapting as the facts evolve.

Find out more about stewardship

In an increasingly volatile world, stewardship is becoming ever more important. Our Stewardship Report 2025 shows how voting, engagement and collaboration can drive meaningful change.

Wealth and purpose

Rewilding: Bringing back the wilderness

Rewilding restores the natural dynamics of damaged ecosystems. We explain why key species, such as rhinos, play a central role in this process, and why successful conservation projects can only be achieved in partnership with the local population.
Wealth and purpose

Transition investments: A pragmatic approach

Polluting industries have no place in a sustainable portfolio - or do they?
Investment strategies

What our ageing population means for investors

Longer lives and lower birth rates are changing demand for everything from health care to housing. Meeting the needs of an ageing population is a key challenge for businesses.
How can investors assess and address nature risks and opportunities, such as ecosystem resilience and nature loss, within their investment process?
Wealth and purpose

Investing in nature?

Nature quietly underwrites the global economy, and investors are beginning to embed the material financial risks and dependencies associated into their investment decisions. We take a look at how biodiversity is reshaping stewardship - and where the opportunities lie.
Wealth and purpose

What is stewardship in investing and why does it matter?

Stewardship is quietly reshaping what it means to invest. No longer just about selecting assets, it reflects a more active role: investors as long-term partners, using their influence to guide companies toward stronger governance, resilience and sustainable growth.
Investment strategies

Who will fund the AI investment boom?

The race to build the next generation of artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly becoming a race for capital. As investment accelerates, the question is who will finance it - and at what price.