Subscribe to our Insights Newsletter

Our Insights provide informative, inspiring, surprising and entertaining insights behind the scenes of finance and business, as well as society and art. The monthly newsletter keeps you up to date.

Innovation and trends

More data, less trust: why the human factor is making a comeback

We know more about each other than ever before - and trust each other less than ever. In this interview, AI researcher and marketing professor Peter Mathias Fischer explains why.

  • Date
  • Reading time 5 minutes

Peter Mathias Fischer argues that, particularly in the age of artificial intelligence, personal customer contact is becoming a real differentiating factor. © istock/da-kuk

Professor Fischer, you specialise in the intersection of data, AI and human behaviour. What has changed most fundamentally for companies in their dealings with clients?

Companies' knowledge of their clients has grown enormously - but so too has the knowledge of the clients themselves. Today, they can access information in real time. At first glance, this sounds like a win-win situation, but it isn't quite that simple. Because this also gives rise to a new challenge: how do you distinguish between fakes and misinformation and what is genuine? We live in an age of both information and disinformation, and that is precisely what breeds mistrust.

That sounds paradoxical: surely more information should lead to greater trust, not less.

That is precisely the irony. Thanks to technology and connectivity, we are better informed today than ever before - and yet we are more distrustful. In an age of countless options, we have rightly become more discerning. This makes it increasingly difficult to forge a lasting, emotional bond between clients and a company.

Peter Mathias Fischer is Professor of Marketing at HEC Paris (École des hautes études commerciales Paris), Academic Director at the Creative Destruction Lab Paris and a member of the University Council at the University of St Gallen. His research focuses on topics at the intersection of strategy, managerial decision-making, international business, (big) data, AI, psychology and technology. He has also been working as a consultant and keynote speaker for over 15 years.

Where do the insights come from that companies use today to try to build this bond?

From data, more than ever before. Websites, apps - every interaction with digital channels is analysed. From these digital footprints, knowledge is generated that is intended to lead to better offers and ultimately increase loyalty. That is the theory.

And in practice?

In practice, this is precisely where the danger lies. Companies can easily lose their way in their digital channels - particularly when these channels serve as both a point of contact for customers and a source of data. They optimise data collection whilst forgetting the people behind it.

Mathias Fischer
"Data is not an end in itself. It is only as good as the people who, with empathy and expertise, translate it into genuine added value."

In your work, you often talk about "high tech and high touch". What exactly do you mean by that?

Particularly in the age of artificial intelligence, personal client contact is becoming a real differentiating factor. For complex products - think of financial services - or for a premium positioning, it is even indispensable. The formula for success is therefore: high tech and high touch. Those who combine a personal approach with state-of-the-art technology offer discerning customers exactly what they want - individual, personalised support, backed by intelligent systems.

You also speak of a "crisis of authenticity"…

When the public increasingly views corporate statements with suspicion, corporate communications are forced onto the defensive. A very concrete example of this is the phenomenon of "greenhushing": companies deliberately refrain from talking about their sustainability achievements - for fear of being accused of greenwashing. This shows just how deep-seated this mistrust has become.

How can companies find their way out of this crisis?

The way customer data is handled could be the key to this. It is not enough simply to interpret customer data correctly. What is crucial is that staff translate this data into offers with genuine added value, drawing on empathy, motivation and expertise. Companies that succeed in doing this are perceived as authentic and particularly trustworthy. And that is precisely what constitutes a strong competitive advantage today.

Finally: if you had to give companies one piece of advice - how should they navigate the tension between data usage and trust?

Data is not an end in itself. It is only as good as the people who translate it into genuine added value with empathy and expertise. Those who understand and put this into practice can successfully set themselves apart from the competition in an age of widespread mistrust.

Investment strategies

Antibiotics: quiet stars in the shadow of blockbusters

Bacterial infections, and particularly the increasing spread of antibiotic resistance, are among the greatest health threats of our time. Despite this, antibiotics have a relatively small share of the global pharmaceutical market. But could this be about to change?
Prinz Max von und zu Liechtenstein
Innovation and trends

The future of private banking: The human factor in the age of AI

Artificial intelligence is transforming industries at extraordinary speed, and private banking is no exception. For H.S.H. Prince Max von und zu Liechtenstein, Chairman LGT, this shift opens up powerful opportunities - and raises fundamental questions about the essence of banking and the value...
Innovation and trends

Data is everywhere - but can we trust it?

Data is vital to most business activities; it's among companies most valuable resource,especially in the age of AI. Which is precisely why we must avoid falling into uncritical use of bits and bytes. The rule still holds: junk in, junk out. Low-quality datasets mislead even the best algorithms,...
How can investors assess and address nature risks and opportunities, such as ecosystem resilience and nature loss, within their investment process?
Wealth and purpose

Investing in nature?

Nature quietly underwrites the global economy, and investors are beginning to embed the material financial risks and dependencies associated into their investment decisions. We take a look at how biodiversity is reshaping stewardship - and where the opportunities lie.